日剧吧 关注：1,742,181贴子：30,924,648
Zhang General August 8th, 2012, 12:29 PM Country: United States
Chinese, Koreans and Japanese...and maybe Mongolians too.
I am aware of the past...but many people don't care, although a lot of people still care.
People talk about the rise of Asia in the 21st C....and an interesting fact is that if east asia combined their GDP and assets it would far surpass both north america and the
european union.
Chinese/Korean vs Japanese or Chinese/Japanese vs Korean or Japanese/Korean vs Chinese?
会出现一个新的东亚联盟吗？
中国人，韩国人和日本人，也许还有蒙古人
我担心的是过去（历史），但是许多人不在乎，也许还有很多人依然在乎
人们谈论21世纪是亚洲世纪，但是一个有趣的事实是东亚的GDP加起来还是比不上北美和欧盟
中/韩vs 日还是中/日vs韩国还是日/韩vs中
Chinese, Koreans and Japanese...and maybe Mongolians too.
I am aware of the past...but many people don't care, although a lot of people still care.
People talk about the rise of Asia in the 21st C....and an interesting fact is that if east asia combined their GDP and assets it would far surpass both north america and the
european union.
Chinese/Korean vs Japanese or Chinese/Japanese vs Korean or Japanese/Korean vs Chinese?
会出现一个新的东亚联盟吗？
中国人，韩国人和日本人，也许还有蒙古人
我担心的是过去（历史），但是许多人不在乎，也许还有很多人依然在乎
人们谈论21世纪是亚洲世纪，但是一个有趣的事实是东亚的GDP加起来还是比不上北美和欧盟
中/韩vs 日还是中/日vs韩国还是日/韩vs中
Quote:
Originally Posted by mingming
It's never going to happen, no matter how strong the economic ties. In the end, everyone is suspicious of everyone else.
What may be possible is that China will work better with the US in years to come. They do hАVe some common interests, and the whole world would benefit from it. If it happened
with jаpan, it's possible with China 在接下来的日子里中国将可能会比美国做的更好。他们有共同利益，整个世界将从中受益。如果日本做到了，中国也会做到 mingming Country: United States
Quote:
Originally Posted by dagul
Not with the Europeans, the Arabs and the Turks.
The EU and the Arab states are not without their own problems 欧盟和阿拉伯国家也没解决自己的问题 WeisSaul Country: United States
jаpan has very recently begun coming out of her self imposed isolationism. jаpan has begun patrolling the Somali coast and is becoming far more assertive with China. jаpan has
recently become Mongolia's prime candidate for a "third neighbor". I think jаpan could end up as a Great power, leading some sort of East Asian bloc involving Vietnam, Thailand,
táiwan, Mongoli, and others to challenge Chinese hegemony.
The US would probably stay close with Korea, who would see the US as a good backer to protect Korean sovereignty from jаpan and China, but due to geography cannot dominate
Korea. 日本近来将摒弃孤立主义。日本开始在索马里巡航，并且在与中国的相处中上过于自信。日本近来成为了蒙古的第三邻居。我认为日本将成为一个巨大的力量，领导东亚国家越南，泰国台湾蒙古还有
其他国家去挑战中国的霸权
美国将会保持与韩国的密切关系，成为韩国免受中日统圌治的保护着，但是基于地理原因无法统圌治韩国。
Originally Posted by mingming
It's never going to happen, no matter how strong the economic ties. In the end, everyone is suspicious of everyone else.
What may be possible is that China will work better with the US in years to come. They do hАVe some common interests, and the whole world would benefit from it. If it happened
with jаpan, it's possible with China 在接下来的日子里中国将可能会比美国做的更好。他们有共同利益，整个世界将从中受益。如果日本做到了，中国也会做到 mingming Country: United States
Quote:
Originally Posted by dagul
Not with the Europeans, the Arabs and the Turks.
The EU and the Arab states are not without their own problems 欧盟和阿拉伯国家也没解决自己的问题 WeisSaul Country: United States
jаpan has very recently begun coming out of her self imposed isolationism. jаpan has begun patrolling the Somali coast and is becoming far more assertive with China. jаpan has
recently become Mongolia's prime candidate for a "third neighbor". I think jаpan could end up as a Great power, leading some sort of East Asian bloc involving Vietnam, Thailand,
táiwan, Mongoli, and others to challenge Chinese hegemony.
The US would probably stay close with Korea, who would see the US as a good backer to protect Korean sovereignty from jаpan and China, but due to geography cannot dominate
Korea. 日本近来将摒弃孤立主义。日本开始在索马里巡航，并且在与中国的相处中上过于自信。日本近来成为了蒙古的第三邻居。我认为日本将成为一个巨大的力量，领导东亚国家越南，泰国台湾蒙古还有
其他国家去挑战中国的霸权
美国将会保持与韩国的密切关系，成为韩国免受中日统圌治的保护着，但是基于地理原因无法统圌治韩国。
现实中无可能
Jake10 Country: Hong Kong
Quote:
Originally Posted by kinger256
China doesn't hАVe any benefit to forming a union with jаpan/korea. They're gonna be a superpower that can exert as much economic and political power as all of Europe in the
future. They don't need anyone to help them.
Korea and jаpan on the other hand is a possibility I can see happen once. Once all the older Korean/jаpanese nationalists die out, people will realize the silliness in fighting
over a small set of rocks that hold no strategic or economic value. South Koreans will face the reality that they are cultural more similar to jаpan then to their brothers up in
the north, and once both countries fade into irrelevance as BRIIC becomes more powerful, they will see the need to form a union of sorts to maintain any type of power in the
future.
Like jаpan said earlier last month, “South Korea shares the closest relationship with jаpan historically and in various areas such as economy and culture.”
China would hАVe a great deal to gain. China has a large, strong labor force, but their designing and engineering sectors are weak. jаpanese and Korean design and engineering
could lead Chinese labor to great improvements.
China also has an array of social problems which education from jаpan could improve, primarily in terms of corruption.
From an economic perspective, a common currency beТWeen the three nations would improve trade.
HАVing said that, we also hАVe to consider the implications and barriers to such a union. Racism and resentment from past events would need to be overcome. As long as people are
unwilling to forgive the ills of WWII, the risk of social anarchy remains. And, as long as intolerance for other cultures persists, a union cannot succeed. 中国将不懈努力，中国有绝大的劳动力。但是设计和工程部门差了。日本和韩国的设计和工程将带领中国的劳动人取得绝大的成就
中国也有一系列的社会问题。这些学习日本将得到改善，主要是贪腐
从经济前景来看，一个共通的货币将在三个国家通行用以提高贸易
我们要考虑联合的意义和障碍。种族主义和历史的恩怨需要被克服。只要人们不愿从将二战的伤痛中走出来，无政圌府主义的风险就依然存在；重要对异族文化的偏见残留，联合就不会成功 puraКJelia Country: Canada
Mongolia and Vietnam also hate China.
It seems that China has bad relationships with almost all of her neighbors. 蒙古和越南也讨厌中国
好像中国与所有的邻居关系都不好 puraКJelia Country: Canada
I don't think such an East Asian union would exist in the perceivable future. Nationalism in those countries hinders the existence of such an union. 在可预见的未来，我认为东亚联盟不会产生。民圌族主义会阻碍联盟的诞生
Quote:
Originally Posted by kinger256
China doesn't hАVe any benefit to forming a union with jаpan/korea. They're gonna be a superpower that can exert as much economic and political power as all of Europe in the
future. They don't need anyone to help them.
Korea and jаpan on the other hand is a possibility I can see happen once. Once all the older Korean/jаpanese nationalists die out, people will realize the silliness in fighting
over a small set of rocks that hold no strategic or economic value. South Koreans will face the reality that they are cultural more similar to jаpan then to their brothers up in
the north, and once both countries fade into irrelevance as BRIIC becomes more powerful, they will see the need to form a union of sorts to maintain any type of power in the
future.
Like jаpan said earlier last month, “South Korea shares the closest relationship with jаpan historically and in various areas such as economy and culture.”
China would hАVe a great deal to gain. China has a large, strong labor force, but their designing and engineering sectors are weak. jаpanese and Korean design and engineering
could lead Chinese labor to great improvements.
China also has an array of social problems which education from jаpan could improve, primarily in terms of corruption.
From an economic perspective, a common currency beТWeen the three nations would improve trade.
HАVing said that, we also hАVe to consider the implications and barriers to such a union. Racism and resentment from past events would need to be overcome. As long as people are
unwilling to forgive the ills of WWII, the risk of social anarchy remains. And, as long as intolerance for other cultures persists, a union cannot succeed. 中国将不懈努力，中国有绝大的劳动力。但是设计和工程部门差了。日本和韩国的设计和工程将带领中国的劳动人取得绝大的成就
中国也有一系列的社会问题。这些学习日本将得到改善，主要是贪腐
从经济前景来看，一个共通的货币将在三个国家通行用以提高贸易
我们要考虑联合的意义和障碍。种族主义和历史的恩怨需要被克服。只要人们不愿从将二战的伤痛中走出来，无政圌府主义的风险就依然存在；重要对异族文化的偏见残留，联合就不会成功 puraКJelia Country: Canada
Mongolia and Vietnam also hate China.
It seems that China has bad relationships with almost all of her neighbors. 蒙古和越南也讨厌中国
好像中国与所有的邻居关系都不好 puraКJelia Country: Canada
I don't think such an East Asian union would exist in the perceivable future. Nationalism in those countries hinders the existence of such an union. 在可预见的未来，我认为东亚联盟不会产生。民圌族主义会阻碍联盟的诞生
mingming Country: United States
It's never going to happen, no matter how strong the economic ties. In the end, everyone is suspicious of everyone else 无论经济关系多密切，这永远不会发生。最后人人都将对他们产生猜疑 dagul Country: Philippines
Quote:
Originally Posted by mingming
US hegemony is already being erased. The age of one superpower is over. The future will be split beТWeen the US and the BRIC nations.
I'll be convinced if we shall now talk in BRIC. In the meantime we are still discussing everything in English. 我确信我们需要谈谈金砖国家。同时我们仍然用英语讨论一切
It's never going to happen, no matter how strong the economic ties. In the end, everyone is suspicious of everyone else 无论经济关系多密切，这永远不会发生。最后人人都将对他们产生猜疑 dagul Country: Philippines
Quote:
Originally Posted by mingming
US hegemony is already being erased. The age of one superpower is over. The future will be split beТWeen the US and the BRIC nations.
I'll be convinced if we shall now talk in BRIC. In the meantime we are still discussing everything in English. 我确信我们需要谈谈金砖国家。同时我们仍然用英语讨论一切
purakjelia Country: Canada
Quote:
Originally Posted by WeisSaul
Japan has very recently begun coming out of her self imposed isolationism. Japan has begun patrolling the Somali coast and is becoming far more assertive with China. Japan has
recently become Mongolia's prime candidate for a "third neighbor". I think Japan could end up as a Great power, leading some sort of East Asian bloc involving Vietnam, Thailand,
Taiwan, Mongoli, and others to challenge Chinese hegemony.
There is no such thing as "Chinese hegemony" nowadays. The days of the Chinese domination of East Asia and the Sinosphere are long gone.
Nowadays, China is just an ordinary developing country with many internal problems yet to be solved.
不存在“中国霸权”。中国对东亚的统治和汉字文化圈都早已远去。
今天，中国依然是一个普通的发展国家，还有很多问题有待解决
Zhang General Country: United States
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Realism
What would the point of such a union be?
Why do they need to form a union to compete with the US? Japan and South Korea get their security from the US.
If the USA and Canada combined, their GDP and economic power would increase too, but for what purpose?
Europe is trying the Union thing and we can see all the kinks involved. I think you underestimate the nationalism in East Asia.
I don't underestimate the nationalism in East Asia. It has a presence there just as strong (if not more) than in Europe and the Middle East. USA is a great ally and asset to
both SOUTH Korea and Japan.
我没有低估东亚的种族主义，像欧洲和中东一样强烈。美国是韩国和日本好的同盟国
Quote:
Korea hates Japan. Korea hates China. Japan and China hate each other too.
What would South Korea and Japan want a union with an authoritarian country?
What are the common interests of the three countries? They are always claiming each others territories and fighting about WW2 and the colonial times.
Why don't you go out some more and meet more real people? Many Koreans don't hate Japanese. I'm pretty sure most Koreans don't hate Chinese either. People or government? Two
different things.
为什么不走出去接触更多的真人呢？许多的韩国人并不讨厌日本人。我也确信多数韩国人不讨厌中国人。人民和政府，还是不同的
Quote:
Originally Posted by WeisSaul
Japan has very recently begun coming out of her self imposed isolationism. Japan has begun patrolling the Somali coast and is becoming far more assertive with China. Japan has
recently become Mongolia's prime candidate for a "third neighbor". I think Japan could end up as a Great power, leading some sort of East Asian bloc involving Vietnam, Thailand,
Taiwan, Mongoli, and others to challenge Chinese hegemony.
There is no such thing as "Chinese hegemony" nowadays. The days of the Chinese domination of East Asia and the Sinosphere are long gone.
Nowadays, China is just an ordinary developing country with many internal problems yet to be solved.
不存在“中国霸权”。中国对东亚的统治和汉字文化圈都早已远去。
今天，中国依然是一个普通的发展国家，还有很多问题有待解决
Zhang General Country: United States
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Realism
What would the point of such a union be?
Why do they need to form a union to compete with the US? Japan and South Korea get their security from the US.
If the USA and Canada combined, their GDP and economic power would increase too, but for what purpose?
Europe is trying the Union thing and we can see all the kinks involved. I think you underestimate the nationalism in East Asia.
I don't underestimate the nationalism in East Asia. It has a presence there just as strong (if not more) than in Europe and the Middle East. USA is a great ally and asset to
both SOUTH Korea and Japan.
我没有低估东亚的种族主义，像欧洲和中东一样强烈。美国是韩国和日本好的同盟国
Quote:
Korea hates Japan. Korea hates China. Japan and China hate each other too.
What would South Korea and Japan want a union with an authoritarian country?
What are the common interests of the three countries? They are always claiming each others territories and fighting about WW2 and the colonial times.
Why don't you go out some more and meet more real people? Many Koreans don't hate Japanese. I'm pretty sure most Koreans don't hate Chinese either. People or government? Two
different things.
为什么不走出去接触更多的真人呢？许多的韩国人并不讨厌日本人。我也确信多数韩国人不讨厌中国人。人民和政府，还是不同的
