Manchester United player ratings: Luke Shaw shines but Mkhitaryan and Lingard have shockers Man City player ratings :De Bruyne, Silva brilliant but Bravo struggles
Mkhitaryan was terrible In the first derby of the season, Manchester United were outplayed by rivals City as Jose Mourinho was outclassed by Pep Guardiola yet again.He was let down by several of his players, though.
Eric Bailly 5 His distribution vexed Mourinho on a number of occasions and his tackling was occasionally reckless. Looked shaky but improved after the pause.
Daley Blind 4 Defended diabolically for Kevin de Bruyne's opener and, as the senior defender, performed like an amateur during that first horrendous half.
Paul Pogba 5 Dithered too often on the ball and struggled to keep up with City's midfield conductors in a game United counted on him to grab by the lapels.
Henrikh Mkhitaryan 3 Started nervously and never recovered. Looked overawed by the occasion and can be grateful his right-sided competitor Lingard also had a shocker.