The hit at 1616 was from a 15in at about 18,000yds range. This shell apparently APC, pierced the Bin upper side armour below No 5 starboard 5.9in gun and 83/oft above the legend water-line, making a circular hole of 21 in outer and 3 9in inner diameter. The after edge of the armour plate was forced 1'/4in to 2in outwards, and the forward edge 3/gin to 1 in, while the bin casemate plate was displaced outwards by up to 3/bin. The shell burst in an outer bunker, and the armour deck, which was here lin at main deck level with a high 2in slope, held and was not pierced, but splinters and armour fragments tore open the 1/4m inner bulkhead of the bunker towards the main deck passage, the 5/16in battery deck was bulged up and holed from below close in rear of the gun, and the 5.9in hoist was torn open by splinters. No 5 gun was out of action and immovable, and the ready ammunition caught fire so that all 12 men in the casemate were killed. Flash passed down the hoist to the magazine, badly burning two men of the magazine party, though two were unhurt. It also entered the main deck passage via the torn bunker bulkhead and caused some casualties there.
Both Nos 4 and 6 starboard 5.9in were temporarily out of action from smoke and gas, and after this cleared the leak was stopped and the only flooding was that of the outer bunker to the top of the armour deck slope for a length of 20ft. Exact details of the coal content of the bunker are lacking, but the Moltke's outer bunkers were not full, though the coal was trimmed to give protection on the outboard side.
Another 15in shell which hit at about this time, struck the side plating a little below the upper deck about 50ft forward of the stern. It passed through the ship and struck the 4in port side armour on the inside at lwl level. The shell does not appear to have exploded, but an armour plate was detached and fell off with a hole c6ft x 5ft in the hull plating inboard, and though the armour deck was intact, a considerable quantity of water entered compartments above this deck for nearly 120ft from the stern.
The hit at 162 3 was again by a 15in. The shell burst on the 103/4in armour belt, 16in above lwl, but below the actual wl, and just abaft No 2 starboard 5.9in. A piece 9in X 121/2in x23/4in deep was broken off the plate surface, and at the 5in lower edge, the plate was driven in Bin with a 3 in deep crack. The skin plating was bulged in by up to 14in for a length of 36ft and to a maximum depth of 8ft below the armour. It was also much torn and pierced in one place by a splinter, while the wing bulkhead was severely bulged. The starboard wings were flooded for 71ft, the protective bunkers for 53ft, the outer bunkers for 32ft to just above the crown of the armour deck at main deck level, and part of the double-bottom adjoining the wings for 16ft. A small amount of water also entered the protective bunkers for a further 33ft forward, but this was drained, and the bunker doors in the undamaged torpedo bulkhead which admitted a little water into Nos 3 and 4 stokeholds, were made tight. Above the water-line the torpedo-net stowage was much damaged, and the net, though undamaged, hung in the water.
The shell that hit at 1626 was also a 15in. This burst on the 103/4in armour belt, 12 in below lwl and a little abaft the main mast. The hit was 28in from the after edge of the plate. There was some spalling of the surface, and the plate, which was cl 7'/2ft long, was forced 12 in inwards at the after edge and 11/2in outward at the forward edge. The next plate aft was forced in 6'/tin at the forward edge and 1'/4in outward at the after edge. Both plates had vertical cracks in the centre area, and the armour deck slope was forced in by up to 10in for a length of 26ft. The hull plating was bulged in by up to 16in for a length of 40ft and to a maximum of Sft below the armour, and was also torn. The starboard wings were flooded for 75ft, the protective bunkers for 63 ft and, above the armour deck, the outer bunkers were flooded for 43ft to a little above the crown of the armour deck at main deck level. Small amounts of water entered the protective bunkers for some distance forward and aft of the flooding, but this was drained away. The torpedo bulkhead remained undamaged and prevented water reaching vital compartments of the ship. Above the water-line the torpedo-net stowage was torn away for 33ft, but the net was not damaged. The range of these shells which hit the main belt was about 16,500-15,500yds.
As a result of these hits the Moltke listed c3° to starboard which was corrected by counter-flooding the port wings. After this had been done, about 1000 tons of water were present in the ship with an increase in draught of c2ft Bin aft and a decrease of c8in forward, but the Moltke was able to maintain 25kts to the end. The 1616 hit by an APC shell should probably be credited to the Valiant, but it cannot be determined whether this ship or the Barham was responsible for the other 15in hits.
The three hits on the von der Tann were as follows: the first being a 15in from the Barham, and the second and third 13.Sin from the Tiger.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8fbc0/8fbc026f5ad0cd48fd14fd2af2d27350dd0d791e" alt=""
Moltke: 15in hit at 1616.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0ef7a/0ef7a16750845aa09fa9f003e0a83c48a41d466a" alt=""
Moltke second 15in hit c1616.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8566b/8566bb0eab08dce575a3d28322ce8969c07c7a71" alt=""
Moltke: hit at 1623.
Hit at 1609. This shell was a CPC fired at a range of about 19,000yds, and hit 28ft from the stern at middle deck level, 3ft above the legend, and probably just below the actual wl. It struck the after side armour on the joint between the 3'/4in upper and 4in lower strakes, and also on a' oint between two upper plates, and 3ft from a joint between two lower plates. The shell burst on the armour and the explosive effect inside the ship was small, but a piece 20in x 28in was broken off the corner of an upper plate, and one 12in x Min off the corner of a lower plate with two fractures 32in distant from it. The armour plates were bent inwards by as much as 32in and also displaced, while the hull plating inboard of the armour was destroyed for a length of 6ft to the main deck and driven 5ft inward. Below the armour the hull plating was bulged inwards to a maximum of 2ft with two vertical cracks 5'/2ft long.
The hull vibrated longitudinally like a tuning-fork, and the main deck was pierced and bulged upwards apparently by armour fragments, the lower support of a 3.5in gun torn away from the middle deck, and this deck damaged and the armour deck distorted at the hull side.
Compartments on the armour deck and some on the middle deck
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/94fc6/94fc611f64efecd3aa65dc7559bcaa4ed6da314b" alt=""
Moltke. hit at 1626.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/efc43/efc43d5297689bed7dc2c8f596936cf7be1c97fa" alt=""
Von der Tann: hit at 1609.
flooded, while a considerable quantity of water entered compartments below the armour deck, and the stern torpedo flat was half filled. The steering-engine ran hot, and the steering compartments flooded, but complete failure of the rudder gear was averted and, after a short interval, the steering gear functioned again, while it was possible to shore the bulkhead leading to the after engine. The change in the ship's draught from 29ft (fore) 28ftlOin (aft) before the battle to 28ft3in (fore), 31 ft2in (aft), with a list of 2° to starboard, after the battle, shows that over 1000 tons of water were present in the ship.